Putter

Blade vs Mallet putter: Which one you should use! Easy guide.

Blade vs Mallet putter

Which putter should I choose, mallet or blade?

It’s a common question beginner golfers ask when picking a new putter for themselves first time and by high handicapper golfers who tried some putters and are still confused about which one they should pick.

I know your concern. I was at that confusion stage when I went to pick the first putter for myself.

But don’t worry. You are in the right hands.

By the end of this article, you will completely understand which putter is the best for you because I will cover all the common questions asked by new golfers and high handicapper golfers about the blade vs mallet putter.

Let’s start the famous discussion about Blade Vs Mallet putter.

How to distinguish which one is mallet or blade putter?

Blade putters are more commonly known as traditional style putters. They are slim, rectangular in shape & lightweight. 

In comparison, the mallet putters are more oversized, commonly square in shape and heavier, as you can see in the picture below.

Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12 Putter

Blade putter has been around since the early days of the game.

In the early days, golfers designed their own clubs out of wood and other material. At that time putter face was usually made with a thin blade attached to a wooden shaft.

As time passed, the putter evolved and the Era of evolved blade putter started when Arnold palmer and jack Nicklaus started to use blade putter in their game in the 1950s and won multiple championships.

Regarding Mallet putter history, their name first emerged in the 1990s and gained widespread attention when professional golfer Mark Calcavecchia started using Odyssey Dual Force Rossie II, a mallet-style putter.

In the later 1990s, only a few professional golfers used mallet putters. But as time passed and people started to use mallet putters and in surveys, before 2017, only 20% of pro players used mallet putters but after 2017 surveys, almost 70% of pro players used mallet putters in their games.

Now you know the brief history of blade vs mallet putter. Now let's move on to the next famous question asked by the golfer.

When it comes to blade vs mallet putters, the deciding factor for many golfers is forgiveness. Forgiving putters help in off- center hits, allowing a golfer to make better contact with the ball and improve their distance accuracy.

Generally speaking, blade putters are less forgiving than mallet putters. Blade putters are usually lighter and feature less perimeter weighting, which means they do not absorb as much of the force from an off center hit.

As a result, blade putters are more difficult for golfers who need help with accuracy and consistency.

Mallet putters, on the other hand, are much more forgiving than blade putters. These putters feature a larger head size and face geometry that allow more weight to be placed around the perimeter of the club head. This additional weight absorbs some of the force from an off center hit, improving accuracy and distance control.

So when it comes down to blade vs mallet putters, if you’re looking for a more forgiving option, the mallet putter is usually the best choice.

When it comes to feeling and feedback, blade putters often provide golfers with more information about their swings than mallets due to the lightweight and thin top line.

Blade putters typically feature a basic head design with a flat face, narrow top line and lighter weight. This design helps golfers develop their touch and feel for the club because there's no extra padding or cushioning to provide feedback.

Whenever the blade makes contact with the ball, golfers get an immediate reaction from the club. This can help golfers adjust their stroke quicker and more effectively than with a mallet putter.

On the other hand, mallet putters typically feature a larger head that's designed for heavier weight and greater forgiveness on off center hits. Mallets are often favoured by beginner golfers, who do not have the feel of blade putters.

Golfers often wonder what is best for alignment between blade and mallet putters, especially when it comes to alignment.

The mallet putter tends to be more accurate when aligning with the ball because of their larger shape, which helps in visual clarity as compared to the blade putter, whose size is smaller.

Conversely, mallets offer many different alignment aids, such as lines, dots and shapes which can help you in your swing. This can significantly benefit the inexperienced golfer looking for assistance with their stroke.

Blade putters generally don't have any alignment aids.

For an arc swing golfer, go for a blade style putter. Because the blade putter is lighter than a mallet putter and light weight allows the golfer to swing the putter in an arc.

The arc swing benefits golfer who want to control their shot on the green.

Mallet putter is best for a straight-back-straight-through swing golfer. The heavier head of the mallet putter helps to stay in the straight patch and does not allow for swinging in arc style.

This straight back straight through swing stroke is best for a new golfer as it helps them in consistent stroke.

For beginner and high handicapper golfers, mallet putters are best for you because their head is larger than blade putter, which helps you hit easily on the putter's sweet spot.

The mallet putter is also forgiving as compared to a blade putter, which means mallet putters are designed in such a way that if you miss hit or off center hit, your shot will still be as affected as you hit the center of the putter face, which is quite beneficial for the new golfer as it builds confidence in golfer and allows you to enjoy the same as pro players.

Another best thing about mallet putters is that they have a higher MOI than blade putters. This high MOI helps stabilize the putter and resist twisting, which helps golfers to hit straight and more accurately.

The mid-handicapper golfer is more experienced as they played many games.

At that stage of the game, it's the personal preference but in my opinion, the mid handicapper should try out the blade style putter because it provides feedback and feel of the shot, which help you judge your shot correctly.

Another great thing about the blade putter is its lightweight, which helps golfers make quick adjustments as they learn and improve their putting strokes.

Mallet Putter

• Jon Rahm (current World No. 1)
• Rory McIlroy
• Scottie Scheffler
• Patrick Cantlay
• Xander Schauffele
• Will Zalatoris
• Justin Thomas
• Viktor Hovland
• Cameron Young
• Billy Horschel

Blade Putter

• Tiger Woods
• Cameron Smith
• Collin Morikawa
• Matt Fitzpatrick
• Jordan Spieth
• Tony Finau
• Tom Kim
• Hideki Matsuyama
• Joaquin Niemann
• Tommy Fleetwood


Mallet Putter Pros:

  • Mallet putters are more forgiving. 
  • Due to their larger heads, making it is easier for beginners to make contact with the ball.
  • Mallet putters generally provide a higher level of accuracy due to the increased stability and reduced twisting at impact resulting from their heavier head weight.
  • The offset hosel design of mallet putters provides many players with improved alignment at address and during the stroke, which can result in reduced mis-hits and straighter lines when putting.
  • Many mallet putters offer adjustable weights that allow golfers to customize the feel and balance of the club head, ensuring an ideal fit for any golfer’s style or preferences.
  • Mallet putters offer a higher MOI (moment of inertia), which helps players generate a more consistent roll on the golf ball, resulting in better distances and improved accuracy.


Cons:

  • Mallet putters are often heavier than blade putters, requiring more force to make a successful putt. This can disadvantage beginner golfers who may not have the upper-body strength needed to hit a solid stroke with a mallet putter.
  • Mallet putters typically require more skill than blade putters, so it could take longer for beginners to get used to the technique of making a successful putt with a mallet club.
  • Mallet clubs tend to be more expensive than blade clubs, so investing in one may not be feasible or desirable for those on a budget or just starting in golf.


Blade Putter Pros:

  • Blade putters are typically lighter, making them easier to swing and reducing fatigue during a long round of golf
  • Blade putters offer increased accuracy, which is great for experienced golfers who prefer to dial in their aim.
  • Blade putters are typically smaller and lighter than mallet putters. They can be easier to maneuver on tight lies and fast greens.
  • Blade putters are often more aesthetically pleasing to many golfers, as they have a classic blade look that appeals to traditionalists.
  • The blade design has less resistance which can help reduce skidding and provide more roll.
  • Blade putters provide greater accuracy and distance control.
  • They are Durable and Reliable.
  • Superior feel, consistency and roll. ​


Cons:

  • The blade design makes blade clubs more prone to twisting on impact with the ball, which could result in an errant shot if you don't have perfect timing and accuracy.
  • The blade shape of the clubface may not provide enough forgiveness when making a stroke if your technique is slightly off-center or otherwise imperfect, resulting in an unsuccessful putt.
  •  Not for Beginners and High handicappers golfers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *